Summary

Provisions restricting government access to software source code have become a standard feature of digital trade agreements. Because artificial intelligence (AI) systems are software, these provisions now sit at the boundary between trade law and AI governance. This working paper examines draft source code rules in the India-European Union (EU) Free Trade Agreement (FTA) from a comparative perspective for understanding their potential implications on Indian digital exports. While the source code rules are largely identical in the FTA with those in the EU’s other major recent Asian FTAs, like those with Korea and Indonesia, the perceived disadvantages for Indian exporters arise from a lack of domestic regulations for AI. The absence of these regulations subjects Indian source codes to the possibility of pre-market reviews in the EU, while no such provisions exist for checking EU source codes in India, except for sensitive sectors like critical infrastructure.

This working paper, however, argues that this imbalance does not constitute the ground for revisiting the source code rules for making them more specific to safeguard against the downsides of high-risk AI systems. On the contrary, it argues for India speeding up the growth of sectoral regulations impacting the use of externally developed frontier AI systems in the country and working closely with the EU in this regard.


Introduction

India and the European Union (EU) concluded negotiations on a bilateral free trade agreement (FTA) on 27 January 2026, with the provisional text of the FTA becoming available soon after. Both sides aim to sign the FTA following the finalisation of the legal text by the end of 2026 and operationalise it by early 2027.[1] The FTA has been widely proclaimed as the ‘mother of all deals’ for creating one of the world’s largest common markets; and the faith of two of the world’s largest economic actors – with historically divergent views on trade – in a comprehensive rules-based framework for advancing mutual trade.[2]

The FTA includes digital trade rules agreed upon by India and the EU. Among India’s new-generation FTAs signed in the current decade, the EU FTA will join those signed by India with the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the United Kingdom (UK) as agreements containing digital trade rules. Salience of these rules in India’s FTAs is significant, given the global growth in digital trade and its growing prominence in India’s external trade.

A critical enabler of bilateral digital trade is the rules regarding disclosure of source code. These provisions in the draft India-EU FTA have generated interest in their potential impact on digital trade. The impact extends to cross-border usage of artificial intelligence (AI) in bilateral trade between India and the EU, along with their capacities to regulate such use.[3] Given the rapid adoption of AI by Indian enterprises in cross-border digital service deliveries, India’s ability to frame effective domestic regulations for AI, and their alignment with similar regulations in major global markets such as the EU, have significant implications for its long-term digital trade prospects.

This paper explores the wider implications of source code rules in the India-EU FTA through a comparative lens. These implications are significant for an economy like India, as it figures among those economies where externally developed AI systems operate at scale across various regulated sectors, with domestic firms often lacking ownership of proprietary software. The comparative lens employed in the paper entails studying a few more major trade agreements with source code provisions. Apart from the India-EU FTA, these include the India-UK Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), signed in July 2025, which, till now, is India’s only other FTA with source-code commitment. Two other major EU trade agreements are also studied. These are the EU-Korea Digital Trade Agreement (DTA)[4] signed on 10 June 2026, and the EU-Indonesia Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement (CEPA), signed and concluded in September 2025.[5] The paper also studies the source code rules in the Comprehensive and Progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), which set the precedent for 21st-century digital trade rules.[6]

The paper is divided into five sections. Section 1 examines source code rules in the draft EU-India FTA text and the need for domestic regulatory catch-up for India. Section 2 studies similar rules across the five mentioned trade agreements. Section 3 discusses India’s disadvantages arising from lesser protection for software exports. Section 4 discusses asymmetry between the EU’s domestic laws and FTA provisions. Section 5 summarises and concludes.


Click Here to Read Full Article : ISAS Working Paper EU-FTA-KK.pdf


(These are the personal views of the author. They do not necessarily reflect the opinion of OP Jindal Global University or its affiliated institutions).